Just as the champions league is a tough competition with
several top sides from the top leagues in Europe, the 'old' UEFA Cup was
also a tough competition for the very same reason.It also
contained teams about to become domestic champions and finals involved
new champions while the old champions final could feature teams already
deposed.
The Champions League is unquestionably a better version than the previous one but it's come at the expense of losing what was a very good competition in its own right. Two if one includes the Cup Winners Cup, particularly as that competition could also feature teams among the best of the rest.
We could retain the best aspects of the champions league and get the other stuff back with a limit of two clubs in the CL from each league currently getting 3 or 4 places. This maintains the strength of the CL by allowing, for example, Real and Barca, Man City & Chelsea, Bayern & Dortmund, Benfica & Porto, Juventus & Milan etc while adding glamour to the Europe (which really needs to be renamed) teams like Inter, ManU, Liverpool, Arsenal, Atletico.
If domestic cup winners were included in the renamed Europa it would be a large tournament but they could split it into two halves, mostly knockout, so there are not too many matches and the two winners of each half BOTH get places in the CL next time but they still play a Cup final, the winners getting a spot in the CL group stage itself.
Winning domestic cups means one can compete with the glamour names of Europe as they are no longer all in the CL and the two CL places available make the second tournament a whole lot more attractive.
You might argue that the big teams won't go for it. But I don't see why not. If you're Arsenal, Liverpool, ManU, Everton, Spurs for example, three of those are not going to get in the CL.
Currently they'll be faced with only one place for the Europa - people forget that two of the three spots go to FA and League Cups - and coming up against many underwhelming names. They'll also consider themselves at a disadvantage the following season by having to play Europa while their other rivals can focus on the league.
All of Arsenal, Liverpool, ManU, Everton, Spurs could instead be looking forward to a more meaningful tournament competing with the sort of teams regularly and currently making the CL quarter final stages.
There really is room for two top tournaments and with no falling from one to the other.
The Champions League is unquestionably a better version than the previous one but it's come at the expense of losing what was a very good competition in its own right. Two if one includes the Cup Winners Cup, particularly as that competition could also feature teams among the best of the rest.
We could retain the best aspects of the champions league and get the other stuff back with a limit of two clubs in the CL from each league currently getting 3 or 4 places. This maintains the strength of the CL by allowing, for example, Real and Barca, Man City & Chelsea, Bayern & Dortmund, Benfica & Porto, Juventus & Milan etc while adding glamour to the Europe (which really needs to be renamed) teams like Inter, ManU, Liverpool, Arsenal, Atletico.
If domestic cup winners were included in the renamed Europa it would be a large tournament but they could split it into two halves, mostly knockout, so there are not too many matches and the two winners of each half BOTH get places in the CL next time but they still play a Cup final, the winners getting a spot in the CL group stage itself.
Winning domestic cups means one can compete with the glamour names of Europe as they are no longer all in the CL and the two CL places available make the second tournament a whole lot more attractive.
You might argue that the big teams won't go for it. But I don't see why not. If you're Arsenal, Liverpool, ManU, Everton, Spurs for example, three of those are not going to get in the CL.
Currently they'll be faced with only one place for the Europa - people forget that two of the three spots go to FA and League Cups - and coming up against many underwhelming names. They'll also consider themselves at a disadvantage the following season by having to play Europa while their other rivals can focus on the league.
All of Arsenal, Liverpool, ManU, Everton, Spurs could instead be looking forward to a more meaningful tournament competing with the sort of teams regularly and currently making the CL quarter final stages.
There really is room for two top tournaments and with no falling from one to the other.